CounterFact Magazine: 1936: What If?

Fourth issue of CounterFact Magazine.

This issue contains:

1936: What If? By Ty Bomba
Terrorism as a Strategy Within Psychological Warfare by Joseph Miranda
Britain's & China's & Japan's New Aircraft Carriers vs. TERN by Chris Perello & Ty Bomba
The Accidental Superpower Book Review, by Ty Bomba
New Column: Sit Reps:
- Hero (Mine Detector) Rats
- Militarized Food
- Russia's New APC Has PlayStation Controls
- China Has Won the "Battle of the Nine-Dash Line"
- US Camouflage Uniforms
- The Lockheed-Martin SR-7
- The Boeing X-51A Waverider
- The Growing Israeli Dolphin-2 Class Submarine Flotilla
- The US Army's "Cheetah" Robot
- The Growing Role of Sepcial Operations Forces & Robots in Militaries Around the World

Game:

1936: What If?, Historically, the French refrained from intervening to block Hitler's 1936 remilitarization of the Rhineland. Their cabinet made that decision based on a report from the Finance Ministry stating the cost of such a move would force them to take the franc off the gold standard and let it float. When the US and British governments, along with those two nations' banking industries, declined to extend the line of credit that would've been needed in order to head off such a potentially panic-inducing economic development, the French decided they couldn't afford to act. The alternative outcome examined here, then, is based on the idea the French either got the loan they needed, or perhaps simply decided the Nazi regime in Germany represented too large a threat to the future of their own republic for it to be allowed to go on unchecked.

More particularly, the scenario starts with the French having mobilized and marched across the Rhineland, stopping at the river. (Historically, the German forces involved in the remilitarization moved across the Rhine bridges with orders to turn about and withdraw immediately if the French advanced.) The further idea is that, within a few hours or days of the French advance, Hitler and his cronies are either dead, jailed or in hiding, due to a Putsch headed by elements within the German military high command. The Nazi Party breaks into factions and starts to war against itself, or simply falls apart into political incoherency. The concentration camps are soon opened by riots among the prisoners within, or perhaps are liberated by angry mobs from without. Either way, the upshot is that all the earlier-imprisoned leaders of Germany's left-wing parties are suddenly back on the political stage.

In Moscow, Stalin quickly comes to understand the opportunity -- likely to be brief -- being presented to him. He announces to the Supreme Soviet the era of "Socialism in One Country" has ended just as suddenly as it began. The time has instead come to forge the iron of international revolution while it is newly hot. "On to Berlin and Socialist World Revolution!" becomes the new slogan of the day. Of course, the Poles resist the effort of the Red Army to cut through their country on its way west.

Thus, within a month or so after their initial intervention, the French must reconcile themselves to the fact that, having come in for a sou they are now irretrievably in for a franc. As the German army begins to fall apart into warring camps (the "Reds" and the "Nationalists"), Paris sends forward its ponderous Rhineland Army Group this time headed for Berlin, there to create a dictat settlement with a new German government of French choosing.

The orders of battle for all participants in the game are accurate as to their historic composition in the early spring of 1936. The only Soviet corps left out are the one they then had in the Trans-Caucasus and the two in the Far East. Further, the Red Army purges hadn't yet begun, so three large mechanized corps are available, along with he world's first paratroop unit as well as its largest cavalry arm.

The first three panzer divisions (all with only Mark I Panzers) start in their countryside training areas, as does the experimental 4th Assault Gun Brigade, which was then dedicated solely to infantry support. The dozen German infantry corps, all of which had historically just completed a rushed year of training (literally and figuratively conducted at "double-time" over the normal two-year cycle), after Hitler's nullification of the army's size limit set by Versailles, are in their Wehrkreis mobilization centers. War and civil war have come early to Germany.

Sequence of play:

I. Soviet Entry Check Phase
II. French Movement Phase
III. Initiative Determination Phase
IV. First Player Turn
A. First Player Movement Phase
B. First Player Combat Phase
C. First Player German Corps Reorganization Phase
V. Second Player Turn
A. Second Player Movement Phase
B. Second Player Combat Phase
C. Second Player German Corps Reorganization Phase

Game Scale:

Game Turn: 7 days
Hex: 40 miles / 64.37 kilometers
Units: Brigade to Army

Game Inventory:

One 17 x 22" full-color mapsheet
One dual-side printed countersheet (88 5/8" counters)
One 8-page 1936: What if? rulebook
One 1-sided Charts & Tables player aid card

Solitaire Suitability: Medium
Complexity Level: Low
Players: 2 or more
Playing Time: 4-6 hours

Note: One 6-sided die is needed for play